Fourth Circuit narrows what an HOA may demand for a fair-housing accommodation
Fourth Circuit narrows what an HOA may demand for a fair-housing accommodation
2026-09-12 · North Carolina · Courts
An association that grants a fair-housing accommodation subject to conditions has made a counter-offer, not an approval — and the legal test looks at the accommodation the resident asked for, not at the conditions the association attached. The Fourth Circuit held so in a published opinion on July 15, 2025.1
The case arose in Maryland, but the Fourth Circuit is the federal appellate court for North Carolina, so this is binding authority in the Eastern, Middle and Western Districts of North Carolina. It is the most consequential fair-housing development for North Carolina associations in the period, and it has had almost no coverage in the state.
What happened
A homeowners association for a private gated community invoked a “business-purpose covenant” to block an assisted-living group home. The owner requested a waiver of the covenant as a reasonable accommodation under the Fair Housing Act.
The association did not refuse outright. It agreed to the accommodation subject to four disputed conditions. The district court granted summary judgment to the association. The Department of Justice and HUD appeared as amici supporting the appellants.
What the court held
The Fourth Circuit vacated summary judgment.
The central holding concerns the “necessary” element of 42 U.S.C. § 3604(f)(3)(B). The district court had asked whether removal of the association's proposed conditions was necessary to afford equal opportunity. That, the Fourth Circuit held, is the wrong question. The statute asks whether the accommodation actually requested — here, the covenant exception — is necessary.
The court was explicit that the difference matters:
This is not just semantics.
The contrary rule, it reasoned, would let a community “impose all kinds of burdensome conditions on accommodation approvals even if they have no relationship to the needs of future residents with disabilities.”
The court also held that a conditional approval operates as a counter-offer — “It is hornbook law that a counter-offer is a rejection” — and that a reasonable jury could find both disability discrimination and retaliation.
It limited itself carefully: “The only thing we hold today is that… there are two sides to this story, not one, making summary judgment inappropriate.”
Keep reading with the North Carolina State Pass
The rest of this analysis — what an association can actually do, the recent bills and rulings, and how North Carolina compares nationally — is for subscribers. $49/month for every North Carolina topic on HOA Weekly.
$49/month, $449/year, or a $19.99 day pass.
What you unlock
- What it changes for North Carolina boards and managers
- Where North Carolina associations meet this
- The state-law backdrop has not moved
and 1 more section in detail
Already a subscriber? Sign in
Recurring monthly subscription · Cancel anytime · Need help?
Related North Carolina HOA Topics
Stay on top of North Carolina HOA law
Every week: new North Carolina legislation, court rulings, and regulatory developments affecting condos, planned communities, and property managers. Free.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.