A mislabelled lis pendens cost $265,000, at $5,000 a lot
A mislabelled lis pendens cost $265,000, at $5,000 a lot
2026-09-15 · Oregon · Courts
A declarant recorded notices of lis pendens against 53 lots in an Oregon planned community and described the object of the suit as enforcing a lien. The suit did not enforce a lien. The bill was $265,000. Calaveras II, LLC v. Eastside Bend, LLC, 350 Or App 259, was decided June 3, 2026 and is precedential.1
What went wrong
ORS 93.740 allows a notice of lis pendens to be recorded, and requires it to include the object of the suit. The notices here described that object as enforcement of a “CC&Rs lien.”
The trial court found the underlying action did not involve a lien of any kind, and on appeal that point was conceded.
The holding on validity
“When that object is described as the enforcement of a lien, when in fact the suit does not seek to enforce a lien, that is not a notice that includes the object of the lawsuit as required by ORS 93.740. Thus, when a recorder of a notice of lis pendens chooses to identify the 'theory' that the notice is based upon in including 'the object of the suit,' they must do so accurately.”
And: “Here, the Notices were invalid because they did not include the object of the suit, because, in fact, the underlying action did not involve the enforcement of a lien. … Therefore, the trial court correctly concluded that the Notices did not comply with their authorizing statute, ORS 93.740, and did not err in granting the petition and striking the Notices under ORS 205.460.”1
The holding on damages
This is the part with the number attached. ORS 205.470 provides minimum statutory damages of $5,000 to “the owner of the property bound by the claim of encumbrance.” The question was what “property” means.
“Bringing that all together, the 'owner of the property bound by the claim of encumbrance,' in ORS 205.470, refers to the owner of title to a specific piece of real property—that is, the 'property' is the individually titled piece of real property bound by the invalid encumbrance. As such, statutory damages are permitted for each property—each unit of land—that has an invalidly encumbered title.”
Not per filing. Not per claimant. Per lot.
Keep reading with the Oregon State Pass
The rest of this analysis — what an association can actually do, the recent bills and rulings, and how Oregon compares nationally — is for subscribers. $49/month for every Oregon topic on HOA Weekly.
$49/month, $449/year, or a $19.99 day pass.
What you unlock
- Why owning many lots does not consolidate the damages
- What it means for Oregon associations
- What a board can do before recording anything
and 2 more sections in detail
Already a subscriber? Sign in
Recurring monthly subscription · Cancel anytime · Need help?
Related Oregon HOA Topics
Stay on top of Oregon HOA law
Every week: new Oregon legislation, court rulings, and regulatory developments affecting condos, planned communities, and property managers. Free.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.