A fifty thousand dollar deductible ceiling
A fifty thousand dollar deductible ceiling
2026-09-15 · Pennsylvania · Compliance
What happened. A hard ceiling arrived on condominium master-policy per-unit deductibles. Since 1 July 2026, for mortgage applications received on or after that date: "If the master property insurance policy includes a per unit deductible, the deductible now may not exceed $50,000 per unit."1 It comes from Freddie Mac Guide Bulletin 2026-C of 18 March 2026, aligned with Fannie Mae.
What it replaced
The previous standard was proportional — a maximum expressed as 5% per unit — together with a route by which an association in certain geographies could cure an excessive deductible through requirements on owners' individual HO-6 policies. Both are retired. A flat dollar ceiling replaces a percentage, and the geographic cure is gone.
The per-occurrence limit remains proportional: "The master property insurance policy deductible(s) for all perils required by Section 4703.2 may not exceed 5% of the limit maintained for dwelling…"1
The obligation that travels with a per-unit deductible
Also effective 1 July 2026: "If a master property insurance policy includes a per unit deductible, then the HO-6 policy must include coverage for all applicable perils to which the per unit deductible applies."1
So the existence of a per-unit deductible in the association's policy now creates a coverage requirement in every mortgaged owner's individual policy. The association's choice reaches into hundreds of separate insurance contracts it is not a party to.
The relief provision
One route out is expressly permitted: "PUDs, ground lease communities, condominium HOAs and Cooperative Corporations may purchase a deductible buy-back insurance policy to meet our deductible requirements, provided the policy meets all other applicable property [insurance requirements]."1
Why associations went to large per-unit deductibles in the first place
Because it was the lever that kept the master policy affordable. As habitational insurance hardened, Pennsylvania associations — like associations everywhere — absorbed premium increases by accepting higher deductibles. A large per-unit deductible transfers the first tranche of any loss from the master policy to the individual owner, and the premium saving is real.
It was, in other words, a deliberate cost-management decision, usually taken with a broker, usually at renewal, and usually without anyone checking it against secondary-market eligibility. That last omission is what now matters.
What actually matters for a board
The distinction between a per-unit and a per-occurrence deductible, because the ceiling applies only to the first and boards routinely do not know which they have.
A per-occurrence deductible applies once to a loss event, however many units are affected. A per-unit deductible applies separately to each damaged unit. A burst riser damaging twelve units generates one deductible under the first and twelve under the second — which is why per-unit deductibles are attractive to insurers and expensive for owners.
The declaration page will say. If it shows a per-unit deductible above $50,000, units in the community have been harder to finance since July, and the board may not have been told.
The Pennsylvania-specific problem: who pays it
A deductible is only a number until a loss allocates it. In Pennsylvania that allocation is governed by the declaration and by 68 Pa.C.S. § 3312 for condominiums and § 5312 for planned communities — neither amended in this session.
Pennsylvania declarations vary widely in how they handle it. Some make the deductible a common expense. Some charge it to the owner of the unit where the loss originated. Some are silent, which produces a dispute every time. An association carrying a $50,000 per-unit deductible under a declaration that is silent has an unallocated $50,000 exposure per damaged unit, and will discover the answer during a claim rather than before one.
The new HO-6 coupling makes getting this right more urgent, not less. An owner whose individual policy must now cover the perils the per-unit deductible applies to needs to know the deductible exists, how large it is, and who bears it — information many Pennsylvania owners have never been given.
The buy-back option, and its honest assessment
A deductible buy-back policy lets the association keep a high deductible on the primary master policy and insure the gap separately. It is expressly permitted, and it is the cleanest technical fix for an association that cannot obtain a compliant deductible at an acceptable premium.
It is not free. The buy-back premium recaptures some of the saving the high deductible produced, and the two policies must fit together — the bulletin's proviso that the policy must meet "all other applicable property insurance requirements" is doing real work. This is a broker conversation, and the right time to have it is well before renewal.
What Pennsylvania regulators are doing about any of this
Nothing directed at it. The Insurance Department's 2025 and 2026 notices address rate-filing modernisation, fidelity and surety deregulation, accident surcharge thresholds, autism coverage and the 1332 reinsurance waiver. None addresses condominium master policies, habitational availability, deductibles or non-renewals.
The one point of contact is that commercial property, businessowners and commercial general liability — the lines a master policy is written on — all remained inside the Department's rate and form filing regime under Notice 2026-07 of April 2026. That is regulatory oversight of the product, not of the eligibility standard, and the eligibility standard is what changed.
What to do before the next renewal
Pull the master policy declaration page and identify the deductible structure. If there is a per-unit deductible, note the figure. If it exceeds $50,000, treat it as a live problem: obtain a compliant quote, price a buy-back, and compare. Then read the declaration on deductible allocation, and if it is silent, get advice on fixing that before a loss makes it urgent. Finally, tell owners what their HO-6 now needs to cover — they cannot comply with a requirement nobody has explained to them.
What to watch next
The same bulletin's remaining dates: the retirement of streamlined project review on 3 August 2026, which has passed, and the increase in minimum replacement reserves to 15% of annual budgeted assessment income on 4 January 2027, which has not. The bulletin also introduces annual insurance verification and borrower reminders by servicers from 1 January 2027, which means the deductible question will be re-asked every year rather than only at sale.
Related Pennsylvania HOA Topics
Stay on top of Pennsylvania HOA law
Every week: new Pennsylvania legislation, court rulings, and regulatory developments affecting condos, planned communities, and property managers. Free.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.