We explain HOA law in plain English, but we are not your lawyer and this is not legal advice. Here is why that matters.

A Georgia couple built a pool pavilion without approval and owe $73,000 in fees

Georgia · Courts

A Georgia couple built a pool pavilion without approval and owe $73,000 in fees

What happened. The Georgia Court of Appeals has affirmed one of the largest architectural-enforcement awards in recent state practice, and in doing so restated three rules that decide most Georgia architectural disputes.

Cotton v. Vinings Estates Community Association, Inc., No. A26A0227, decided 6 May 2026. Dillard, P.J., with Gobeil and Pipkin, JJ., concurring. Published; affirmed in full.1

The facts

The Cottons built a non-compliant outdoor kitchen and pool pavilion in Mableton without architectural review committee approval, and finished it after being warned more than once to stop.

A jury awarded the association $6,475 in unpaid fines and $73,000 in attorney's fees and costs. The trial court then entered a permanent injunction ordering complete removal and restoration.

The fee award is more than eleven times the fines. That ratio is the practical lesson of the case.

Rule one: “greater restrictions” did not save them

The Cottons argued that the ARC's written design guidelines — as distinct from the recorded declaration — were unlawful greater restrictions under O.C.G.A. § 44-5-60(d)(4), which they had never consented to in writing.

The court quoted the statute and then closed the door: “by consenting to be bound by the Declaration, the Cottons agreed in writing that the HOA or its designee reserved the right to implement new guidelines for building detached structures.”

The declaration said the Board or its designee “shall be the sole arbiter of such plans and may withhold approval for any reason, including purely aesthetic considerations.”

Rule two: the Saunders standard is deferential

They invoked Saunders v. Thorn Woode Partnership, L.P., 265 Ga. 703 (1995): where a declaration delegates decision-making to a group, “the only judicial issues are whether the exercise of that authority was procedurally fair and reasonable, and whether the substantive decision was made in good faith, and is reasonable and not arbitrary and capricious.”

The court noted in a footnote that Saunders itself never reached arbitrariness, and rejected the attempt to sort design guidelines into “substantive” and optional categories.

Rule three: no balancing of the harms

This is the sharpest holding, and the one Georgia homeowners most often do not expect. Irreparable harm arises “as a matter of law arising from a violation of a covenant running with the land,” so “no special showing of irreparable harm is ‘necessary other than the violation of a valid restrictive covenant.’”

Therefore “the trial court was not required to balance the harms between the parties.” The cost of demolishing a finished pavilion does not enter the analysis.

Keep reading with the Georgia State Pass

The rest of this analysis — what an association can actually do, the recent bills and rulings, and how Georgia compares nationally — is for subscribers. $49/month for every Georgia topic on HOA Weekly.

$49/month, $449/year, or a $19.99 day pass.

What you unlock

  • The selective-enforcement defence that never got heard
  • Why the fees were eleven times the fines
  • What changed on 1 July 2026

and 3 more sections in detail

Unlock Georgia

Already a subscriber? Sign in

Recurring monthly subscription · Cancel anytime · Need help?

Related Georgia HOA Topics

← All Georgia HOA Topics

  1. Cotton v. Vinings Estates Community Association, Inc., No. A26A0227 (Ga. Ct. App. 6 May 2026) — slip opinion ↩
  2. Senate Bill 406, as passed (26 LC 49 2879S) — signed copy, Office of the Governor ↩
  3. Ellington Homeowners Association, Inc. v. Ibrahim, No. A25A0707 (Ga. Ct. App. 19 May 2025) — slip opinion ↩

Stay on top of Georgia HOA law

Every week: new Georgia legislation, court rulings, and regulatory developments affecting condos, planned communities, and property managers. Free.

Check your inbox to complete your sign up.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.