We explain HOA law in plain English, but we are not your lawyer and this is not legal advice. Here is why that matters.

Idaho Court of Appeals: a 1979 "no commercial enterprises" clause does not bar Airbnb

Idaho · Courts

Idaho Court of Appeals: a 1979 "no commercial enterprises" clause does not bar Airbnb

What happened. The Idaho Court of Appeals decided Delano v. Pike, Docket No. 527233, on 10 December 2025, holding that a covenant prohibiting commercial enterprises while permitting “the private renting of a dwelling” does not prohibit an owner from listing that dwelling on Airbnb.1 Judge Huskey wrote; Judges Lorello and Tribe concurred. The judgment dismissing the neighbours' complaint was affirmed.

This is a covenant-construction case, and it is distinct from the statutory consent question the Supreme Court answered a month later in North Henry's Lake. Here there was no statute in the way — only the words the drafters chose in 1979.

One paragraph, thirty lots

Swan Shores is a thirty-lot neighbourhood in Bonner County, platted in 1979, with covenants adopted that year and amended in 1980. The entire dispute turned on paragraph 6:

  • Swan Shores CC&Rs, paragraph 6 (adopted 1979)No commercial enterprises shall be conducted upon said real property. This shall not prevent the private renting of a dwelling on any lot.

The Pikes had listed their home on Airbnb from time to time. When they put it on the market and the listing noted the home could be rented as a vacation rental, several neighbours sued for declaratory relief. Both sides moved for judgment on the pleadings under I.R.C.P. 12(c), and both told the district court that paragraph 6 was plain and unambiguous — they simply disagreed about what it plainly meant. The district court (First Judicial District, Bonner County, Judge Lamont C. Berecz) granted the Pikes' motion and dismissed.

The rule the Court applied

The controlling authority is Pinehaven Planning Board v. Brooks, 138 Idaho 826 (2003), where the Idaho Supreme Court held that renting property for residential purposes, “whether short or long-term,” does not violate a prohibition on commercial and business activity as those terms are commonly understood.

Layered on top is the free-use canon from Jacklin Land Co. v. Blue Dog RV, Inc., 151 Idaho 242 (2011): because restrictive covenants derogate from the common-law right to use land for all lawful purposes, they are not extended by implication, and all doubts resolve in favour of free use. The district court's conclusion followed directly — paragraph 6 does not clearly prohibit short-term rentals, so the doubt goes to the owner.

Keep reading with the Idaho State Pass

The rest of this analysis — what an association can actually do, the recent bills and rulings, and how Idaho compares nationally — is for subscribers. $49/month for every Idaho topic on HOA Weekly.

$49/month, $449/year, or a $19.99 day pass.

What you unlock

  • Three arguments the neighbours lost
  • Fees, and how the neighbours earned them at oral argument
  • What it means for Idaho associations
Unlock Idaho

Already a subscriber? Sign in

Recurring monthly subscription · Cancel anytime · Need help?

Related Idaho HOA Topics

← All Idaho HOA Topics

  1. Delano v. Pike, Docket No. 52723 (Idaho Ct. App., Dec. 10, 2025) (slip opinion) ↩
  2. Idaho Code § 55-3211, rental restrictions require the affected owner's written consent ↩
  3. Delano v. Pike, docket record (CourtListener) ↩

Stay on top of Idaho HOA law

Every week: new Idaho legislation, court rulings, and regulatory developments affecting condos, planned communities, and property managers. Free.

Check your inbox to complete your sign up.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.