We explain HOA law in plain English, but we are not your lawyer and this is not legal advice. Here is why that matters.

A New York co-op had three months to enforce its no-pit-bull rule. It waited, and the rule was gone.

New York · Courts

A New York co-op had three months to enforce its no-pit-bull rule. It waited, and the rule was gone.

The New York City Pet Law gives a building three months from discovering an openly harboured pet to sue. A cooperative that misses that window loses the rule — and on January 21, 2025 the Appellate Division, First Department confirmed that a no-waiver clause in the proprietary lease does not rescue it, and neither does the business judgment rule.

In 360 East 72nd Street Owners Inc. v Wolkoff, 2025 NY Slip Op 00284, 234 AD3d 565, the court affirmed a judgment against the cooperative on both the waiver point and, after a hearing, on the nuisance exception.1

The waiver holding

“Supreme Court properly determined that the cooperative failed to commence this action against defendant to enforce its house rule banning pit bulls within the three-month period of discovering that the dog was a pit bull, resulting in a waiver of the provision under Administrative Code § 27-2009.1 (b), known as the 'pet law.' The court properly rejected the cooperative's reliance on its building's 'pet friendly' policy, which only bans the 'most aggressive' dog breeds, the business judgment rule, and the proprietary lease's 'no waiver' clause to overcome the pet law. This Court has long held that the pet law applies to all leases, including cooperative apartment proprietary leases, even where, as here, the cooperative's proprietary lease contains a 'no waiver' clause (see Seward Park Hous. Corp. v Cohen, 287 AD2d 157, 162 [1st Dept 2001]).”

Three defences, all rejected: the building's own policy language, the business judgment rule, and the no-waiver clause.

And the nuisance exception

The Pet Law allows enforcement past three months where the pet causes damage or a nuisance. The court set out the standard:

“In order to enforce the house rule beyond the three-month period, the cooperative was required to show that the pet law's exception under Administrative Code § 27-2009.1 (d) applied by establishing 'the harboring of a household pet causes damage to the subject premise, creates a nuisance or interferes substantially with the health, safety or welfare of other tenants or occupants of the same or adjacent building or structure'…”

Then the sentence that decides most of these cases:

“Supreme Court also properly rejected the cooperative's insistence that the dog's breed was relevant to whether this particular dog was a nuisance (see Carter v Metro N. Assoc., 255 AD2d 251, 251-252 [1st Dept 1998]).”

Keep reading with the New York State Pass

The rest of this analysis — what an association can actually do, the recent bills and rulings, and how New York compares nationally — is for subscribers. $49/month for every New York topic on HOA Weekly.

$49/month, $449/year, or a $19.99 day pass.

What you unlock

  • What the three-month clock actually runs from
  • Breed-based rules are the weakest kind in New York City
  • What a New York City board can do

and 1 more section in detail

Unlock New York

Already a subscriber? Sign in

Recurring monthly subscription · Cancel anytime · Need help?

Related New York HOA Topics

← All New York HOA Topics

  1. 360 East 72nd Street Owners Inc. v Wolkoff, 2025 NY Slip Op 00284, 234 AD3d 565 (1st Dept, January 21, 2025) ↩
  2. Manculich v Five Riverside Towers Owners, Inc., 2026 NY Slip Op 50635(U) (Sup Ct, Broome County, April 27, 2026) ↩

Stay on top of New York HOA law

Every week: new New York legislation, court rulings, and regulatory developments affecting condos, planned communities, and property managers. Free.

Check your inbox to complete your sign up.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.