We explain HOA law in plain English, but we are not your lawyer and this is not legal advice. Here is why that matters.

Pleading in contract no longer kills a builder's defect coverage

Oregon · Courts

Pleading in contract no longer kills a builder's defect coverage

The Oregon Supreme Court has removed the pleading trap that insurers used to defeat construction-defect coverage. Twigg v. Admiral Insurance Company, 373 Or 445, was decided April 17, 2025, and it matters to every Oregon association pursuing a builder.1

The problem it solves

Commercial general liability policies cover “property damage” caused by an “occurrence,” which the policies define as an accident. Insurers have long argued that where the underlying claim against the builder was pleaded and resolved in contract, there was no accident — only a breach — and therefore no coverage.

That argument had real force in Oregon, because construction-defect claims are frequently framed in contract, and because arbitration awards often do not specify a theory.

The holding

“Whether an insurance claim seeks recovery for an 'accident' does not depend on a plaintiff's pleading decisions in the underlying claim against the insured but depends instead on whether there is a basis in fact for imposing tort liability.”1

Applied to the facts: “Applying that rule of construction, we conclude that, to establish the property damage alleged here was caused by an 'accident' within the meaning of defendant's CGL policy, plaintiffs were not required to formally allege a tort claim or obtain an award in tort. Rather, plaintiffs were required to establish that there was a basis in fact for imposing tort liability on Rainier Pacific, even though the same facts may have established Rainier Pacific's liability in contract.”

And the underlying principle: “It is well settled that the mere fact that an insured was in a contractual relationship with a plaintiff does not foreclose the possibility of liability to that plaintiff in tort, in addition to contract.”

Disposition

“The decision of the Court of Appeals is reversed. The judgment of the circuit court is reversed, and the case is remanded to the circuit court for further proceedings.”

The homeowners had arbitrated defect claims against their builder and then pursued the builder's CGL insurer. Both lower courts had gone against them.

Keep reading with the Oregon State Pass

The rest of this analysis — what an association can actually do, the recent bills and rulings, and how Oregon compares nationally — is for subscribers. $49/month for every Oregon topic on HOA Weekly.

$49/month, $449/year, or a $19.99 day pass.

What you unlock

  • How the court got there
  • What this means for an Oregon association
  • Where it sits against the new statute

and 1 more section in detail

Unlock Oregon

Already a subscriber? Sign in

Recurring monthly subscription · Cancel anytime · Need help?

Related Oregon HOA Topics

← All Oregon HOA Topics

  1. Twigg v. Admiral Insurance Company, 373 Or 445 (April 17, 2025), SC S070191 — official opinion ↩
  2. Supreme Court opinions, Oregon Judicial Department ↩

Stay on top of Oregon HOA law

Every week: new Oregon legislation, court rulings, and regulatory developments affecting condos, planned communities, and property managers. Free.

Check your inbox to complete your sign up.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.