Montana HOA Fining Authority
Montana HOA Fining Authority
Section 1: Overview — Fining authority in Montana
Montana takes a narrower path than most states. One statute, the Unit Ownership Act, covers condominiums — and nothing on the books covers planned-community homeowners' associations at all. Fining authority in both settings traces back to the CC&Rs, not a statute, and Montana adds one more quirk: no intermediate appellate court stands between the trial-level District Courts and the Montana Supreme Court.
The Montana Unit Ownership Act, Mont. Code Ann. § 70-23-101 et seq., governs condominiums submitted to it.1 Lawmakers passed it in 1965, long before the Uniform Common Interest Ownership Act existed, and it grants no express power to fine. Planned communities get even less: Montana has no dedicated statute for them at all. Their fining authority comes straight from the recorded declaration and bylaws, while the Montana Nonprofit Corporation Act, Mont. Code Ann. § 35-2-113 et seq., supplies the corporate formalities for the many associations organized as nonprofit corporations.2 Because the fine's authority is contractual, the real limits are whatever the declaration says, backed by the common-law expectation that a fine stay reasonable and follow reasonable notice and a chance to respond.3
The question that matters most downstream: can an unpaid fine become a recorded lien and support foreclosure? For condominiums, the Act's lien secures "common expenses" — a defined term that doesn't plainly reach fines. For planned communities, a lien right exists only if the declaration creates one.4 The Quick-Reference table below works through that analysis, and Section 3C develops it further.
Keep reading with the Montana State Pass
The rest of this analysis — what an association can actually do, the recent bills and rulings, and how Montana compares nationally — is for subscribers. $49/month for every Montana topic on HOA Weekly.
$49/month, $449/year, or a $19.99 day pass.
What you unlock
- Section 2: Quick-Reference Fining Mechanics Table
- Section 3: Fining mechanics in detail
- Section 4: Recent legislative and judicial activity
and 9 more sections and subsections in detail
Already a subscriber? Sign in
Recurring monthly subscription · Cancel anytime · Need help?
Related Montana HOA Topics
- Mont. Code Ann. § 70-23-101 (Short title, "Unit Ownership Act"), MCA; chapter table of contents, Title 70, ch. 23 ↩
- Montana Nonprofit Corporation Act, Mont. Code Ann. Title 35, ch. 2 (§ 35-2-113 et seq.); Montana Legislative Local Government Interim Committee, "HOA Governance in Montana" (2024) (Montana has no single HOA act; most associations organize under Title 35, ch. 2) ↩
- Windemere Homeowners Ass'n, Inc. v. McCue, 1999 MT 292, 297 Mont. 77, 990 P.2d 769 (restrictive covenants strictly construed; ambiguities resolved in favor of free use of property; covenants not extended by implication or enlarged by construction); see also Town & Country Estates Ass'n v. Slater, 227 Mont. 489, 740 P.2d 668 (1987) ↩
- Mont. Code Ann. § 70-23-607 (lien for "common expenses"), MCA; § 70-23-102(4) (definition of "common expenses") ↩
- Mont. Code Ann. Title 70, ch. 23, Part 10 ("Enforcement and Penalty (Repealed)"); §§ 70-23-1001 and 70-23-1002, "Repealed. Sec. 3, Ch. 12, L. 1999" ↩
- Mont. Code Ann. § 70-23-506 (compliance with bylaws, rules, and covenants required; failure to comply is grounds for an action maintainable by the association or an aggrieved unit owner) ↩
- Mont. Code Ann. § 70-23-308 (contents of bylaws, including "the manner of collecting from the unit owners their share of the common expenses") ↩
- Mont. Code Ann. § 35-2-520 (Termination, expulsion, and suspension; fair-and-reasonable-procedure safe harbor of 15 days' prior written notice and an opportunity to be heard not less than 5 days before the effective date; one-year limitation to challenge) ↩
- Mont. Code Ann. § 70-23-607 (Claim for common expenses -- priority of lien -- contents -- recording; lien prior to all other liens except tax/assessment liens and a recorded first mortgage or trust indenture; verified claim must be recorded) ↩
- Mont. Code Ann. § 70-23-102(4) (definition of "common expenses") ↩
- Mont. Code Ann. § 70-23-608 (Foreclosure of lien under claim for common expenses -- action without foreclosure; proceedings conform to Title 71, ch. 3, part 5) ↩
- Montana Legislature ("The Legislature meets in regular session for up to 90 working days of every odd-numbered year") ↩
- Montana 69th Legislature (2025): SB 431 and HB 761 (covenant/HOA restriction bills) not enacted; related SB 400 "Died in Standing Committee" (2025-05-23); see Montana Legislature Bill Explorer, bills.legmt.gov ↩
- Mont. Code Ann. § 70-17-210 (Covenant enforcement and abandonment), "amd. Sec. 1, Ch. 258, L. 2025; amd. Sec. 1, Ch. 423, L. 2025"; HB 325 and HB 147 (2025) enrolled texts ↩
- Clover Meadows Homeowners Ass'n, Inc. v. Spear, 2024 MT 102N, DA 23-0334 (Mont. May 14, 2024) (memorandum opinion; noncitable and not precedent under the Court's Internal Operating Rules) ↩
- 47 C.F.R. § 1.4000 (OTARD rule; prior-approval requirement is itself a prohibited restriction; no penalty accrues against the antenna user while a dispute is pending) ↩
- Watts v. Joggers Run Property Owners Ass'n, Inc., 133 F.4th 1032, No. 22-13763 (11th Cir. Apr. 7, 2025) (selective enforcement of parking, pet, and penalty-fee rules against a protected class states a Fair Housing Act claim) ↩
Stay on top of Montana HOA law
Every week: new Montana legislation, court rulings, and regulatory developments affecting condos, planned communities, and property managers. Free.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.