We explain HOA law in plain English, but we are not your lawyer and this is not legal advice. Here is why that matters.

A motocross course is not a “residential” use, Montana's high court holds

Montana · Courts

A motocross course is not a “residential” use, Montana's high court holds

What happened. A Montana association does not have to prove a business is being run to enforce a “residential purposes only” covenant. A recreational installation can breach it on its own.

The decision

Larsen v. Sayers, 2025 MT 24, 420 Mont. 270, 563 P.3d 269, docket DA 24-0151, decided February 4, 2025. Justice Baker wrote for the Court. Published and citable. On appeal from the Second Judicial District Court, Butte-Silver Bow County (Hon. Kurt Krueger), which had held after a bench trial that the motocross activities did not violate the covenants.1

The covenant

Section 1 of the McGuiness Tracts declaration provided that lots

“shall be used for residential and agricultural purposes only, … and no business, trade, manufacture or other commercial activity shall be conducted thereon”

with a separate clause barring use that “unreasonably disturb[s] the owners of tracts located in the said real property.”

The holding

The Court found the declaration not ambiguous. “Residential” means “used as a residence or by residents,” per Hillcrest, 239 Mont. 56, 778 P.2d 423. The defendants' own testimony did much of the work: one agreed at trial that a motocross course is not a residential or agricultural use, and the other conceded motocross is not necessary to a residence.

The Court rejected the argument that using the course incidentally to living on the property made the course itself residential. It reversed on breach of the residential-use covenant and on injunctive relief, affirmed that ramp-building did not violate the commercial-activity restriction on this record, and reversed the denial of attorney fees, remanding to set a reasonable award for the enforcing neighbours.

Keep reading with the Montana State Pass

The rest of this analysis — what an association can actually do, the recent bills and rulings, and how Montana compares nationally — is for subscribers. $49/month for every Montana topic on HOA Weekly.

$49/month, $449/year, or a $19.99 day pass.

What you unlock

  • The rule that transfers: ancillary is not residential
  • Two other reasons this opinion keeps appearing
  • The evidentiary lesson, which is unglamorous and decisive

and 1 more section in detail

Unlock Montana

Already a subscriber? Sign in

Recurring monthly subscription · Cancel anytime · Need help?

Related Montana HOA Topics

← All Montana HOA Topics

  1. Larsen v. Sayers, 2025 MT 24, 420 Mont. 270, 563 P.3d 269 (DA 24-0151, Feb. 4, 2025), slip opinion (Montana Judicial Branch document service) ↩
  2. Brandt v. R&R Mountain Escapes, LLC, 2025 MT 155 — citing Larsen ¶ 37 on prevailing-party fees ↩

Stay on top of Montana HOA law

Every week: new Montana legislation, court rulings, and regulatory developments affecting condos, planned communities, and property managers. Free.

Check your inbox to complete your sign up.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.