We explain HOA law in plain English, but we are not your lawyer and this is not legal advice. Here is why that matters.

A Maryland property manager got 20 years for running a Ponzi scheme through the HOA accounts she managed

A Maryland property manager got 20 years for running a Ponzi scheme through the HOA accounts she managed
Maryland · Courts

A Maryland property manager got 20 years for running a Ponzi scheme through the HOA accounts she managed

What happened. On 11 May 2026 a Nottingham property manager pleaded guilty in the Circuit Court for Harford County to running a scheme through the homeowners-association accounts she managed, and was sentenced to 20 years, all suspended but five years to serve. She was taken into custody immediately. Restitution is expected to reach close to $600,000.1

The manager was Sarah Chester, 44, owner of Magnolia Properties. She pleaded guilty before Judge Paul W. Ishak to theft scheme over $100,000, forgery and counterfeiting of private documents, and embezzlement. Prosecutors put the affected population at more than 250 households and roughly 1,500 individuals across associations in Harford and Baltimore counties. Over 50 residents attended the sentencing.12

The mechanism

The scheme ran from 2021 to 2025, and its structure is the part relevant to every Maryland board:1

  • She siphoned funds from each association into personal accounts.
  • She fabricated bank statements to present to boards.
  • She transferred money between the associations' accounts to cover the resulting shortfalls — which is what makes it a Ponzi structure rather than simple theft, and what let it survive four years.
  • The proceeds funded trips to Europe and country-club memberships.

It was uncovered by the Hamilton Reserve HOA board, shortly after Thanksgiving 2025. Not by an auditor, not by a bank, not by a regulator — by volunteers looking at their own accounts.

Restitution was left open for 30 days after sentencing to verify amounts across the affected associations. It was prosecuted by Assistant State's Attorney Ari Kodeck under State's Attorney Alison M. Healey.

✓ Your Maryland State Pass is active — the full analysis below is unlocked

Why the cross-association transfers matter so much

A manager holding one association's funds who steals from it produces a visible hole at a predictable moment: the next bank reconciliation, the next audit, the next large payment.

A manager holding several associations' funds can move money between them, so each individual account looks plausible when anyone happens to check it. The shortfall exists in aggregate and nowhere in particular. Combine that with fabricated statements and there is no document in front of any board that shows anything wrong.

The structural implication is uncomfortable: the ordinary controls a Maryland board relies on cannot detect this pattern. Reviewing a monthly statement supplied by the manager is useless when the statement is manufactured. Comparing the balance to the budget is useless when the balance has been topped up from a neighbouring community.

What does detect it is confirmation from outside the manager's control — the board receiving statements directly from the financial institution, or a board member with independent view-only access to the account. That distinction, between a statement the manager gives you and a statement the bank gives you, is the whole of it.

Four years and roughly $600,000 is the cost of not having it.

Maryland gave associations a bigger reserve to guard, and no licensing for the people guarding it

The timing here is worth setting out plainly.

Since 1 October 2025 Maryland condominiums, HOAs and cooperatives must fund reserves to the level their reserve study recommends, and deposit the contribution by the end of each fiscal year. That is the point of Chapters 518 and 519 of the Acts of 2025, and it means Maryland associations are now required by law to accumulate larger cash balances than most of them previously held.

Over the same period the legislature has declined, four sessions running, to license the managers who administer those balances. HB 853 would have created a State Board of Common Ownership Community Managers with mandatory licensing; it died in House Economic Matters this year without a committee vote. HB 1644, which would have licensed managers through the existing State Real Estate Commission instead, never got a hearing.3 Earlier versions died in 2023, 2024 and 2025.

Maryland therefore requires bigger reserves and regulates the custodians not at all. That is not an argument for any particular bill — the licensing proposals have real costs, and the fiscal note put HB 853's first-year figure at $224,600 — but it is the arithmetic a board is operating inside.

What does reach a Maryland manager

Three things, none of them a licence:

Criminal law. This case. Theft scheme over $100,000 under Criminal Law § 7-104, forgery of private documents under § 8-601, and embezzlement.

Consumer-protection enforcement. Since October 2025 the Attorney General's Consumer Protection Division has had enforcement jurisdiction over every violation of the Condominium Act and the HOA Act. In December 2025 it obtained a Final Order against a different community-association management company over unlawful late fees, carrying $1.3 million in civil penalties and $179,000 in costs — and ordering restoration of more than $25,000 that a principal had withdrawn from an association's bank account without authorisation.4 That last element is the same category of conduct as this prosecution, pursued civilly.

County registration, in two counties. Prince George's County requires management companies to register annually and pay $100, and its March 2026 rules make the management company primarily responsible for document compliance, with fines up to $5,000 recoverable from the management contract. Montgomery County reaches managers through its commission. Neither is a competence check, but both create a record of who is managing what.

Harford County, where this case was prosecuted, has neither.

What to watch next

The restitution figure. It was left open for 30 days after the 11 May sentencing to verify amounts across the affected associations, and the final number has not, as far as we can find, been published. For the associations involved, that figure — and what proportion is actually recovered — determines whether their reserves survive this.

And whether any of it reaches the 2027 session. A concrete Maryland case with a conviction, a dollar figure and 1,500 affected residents is the sort of thing a manager-licensing bill has lacked in four previous attempts. Pre-file drafting requests are due 20 November 2026 for a session convening 13 January 2027.

Related Maryland HOA Topics

← All Maryland HOA Topics

  1. Office of the State's Attorney for Harford County — Nottingham Woman Convicted in HOA Theft Scheme: the guilty plea of 11 May 2026 before Judge Paul W. Ishak, the 20-year sentence with five years to serve, the charges, the 2021-2025 period, the fabricated bank statements and inter-association transfers, and the Hamilton Reserve HOA board's discovery
  2. Patch (Bel Air), 19 May 2026 — reporting on the sentencing, the restitution figure approaching $600,000, the 250-plus households and roughly 1,500 individuals affected, and the 30-day period left open to verify amounts
  3. House Bill 853 (2026), Real Property – Regulation of Common Ownership Community Managers — died in House Economic Matters without a committee report (see also HB 1644, which would have licensed managers through the State Real Estate Commission and never received a hearing)
  4. Office of the Attorney General of Maryland, Final Order against a community-association property manager, 3 December 2025 — $1.3 million in civil penalties, $179,000 in costs, and restoration of more than $25,000 withdrawn from an association's account without authorisation

Stay on top of Maryland HOA law

Every week: new Maryland legislation, court rulings, and regulatory developments affecting condos, planned communities, and property managers. Free.

Check your inbox to complete your sign up.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.